22 Mar 2017
The private equity industry is embracing investor and regulator demands for greater transparency following the financial crisis. But can the push to ever-more disclosure be a bad thing? It’s time for an honest debate about what information investors need and what managers should provide.
The drive towards greater transparency started with the financial crisis when investors and regulators found that portfolios of what they believed were low-risk investments contained toxic elements. The result was a swathe of tougher rules from regulators designed to protect investors, as well as increased demand from investors for more granular analysis of assets so that they could understand the risks and set aside appropriate levels of regulatory capital.
Managers and investors understand greater transparency to be a good thing. It has made private equity more open and accessible to all manner of investors, ultimately driving assets under management. But it also puts huge burdens on the private equity industry and can ultimately distract from the job in hand – investing in and managing companies around Europe to deliver superior returns.
Large financial institutions like insurers, managing billions of euros of assets, have the resources to meet the risk management and transparency requirements of regulation like Solvency II. They, in turn, are placing more demands on private equity to meet higher standards – and many managers are having a tough time responding to this pressure.
Firms need to invest in and maintain new systems to track and report on their investments. Their people must spend more time on gathering investment data and reporting back to investors, or they need to hire new people to take on this role. Furthermore, the advent of dynamic reporting – disclosure tailored to individual investor’s needs – to replace standardised reports, adds an additional layer of complexity. What if all that time spent on disclosure hindered investment performance or industry development, would it be such a good thing then?
Large private equity managers – like the large institutions they serve – are starting to tackle the demands with new infrastructure and new people. However, smaller investment managers in the mid-market and lower mid-market often lack the scale and resources to build these operations. Moreover, new managers may be put off forming because the barriers to entry are simply too high.
Associations like Invest Europe and the Institutional Limited Partners Association (ILPA) have helped by defining best practice reporting standards. These have pushed large parts of the industry to be more open with investors.
Yet limited partners should be cautious about pushing for transparency for transparency’s sake, and need to recognise the different capacities of investment managers to meet complex reporting demands. Meanwhile, for general partners, data is the key. Gathering and managing robust data on investments will help them meet investors’ demands and adapt to new requirements.
It’s time for an open debate about what disclosure is needed, how it may impact private equity focus, and how transparency is best served. Please join me at the Investors’ Forum in Geneva where I will be discussing this topic and others relating to the changing LP/GP relationship.
Paul Lawrence is Global Head of Fund Services at Intertrust.
Most PCs automatically accept them but you can change your browser settings to restrict, block or delete cookies if you want. Each browser is different, so check the 'Help' menu of your particular browser (or your mobile phone's handset manual) to learn how to change your cookie preferences. Many browsers have universal privacy settings for you to choose from.
Cookie settings in most versions of Internet Explorer can be found by clicking the tools option and then the privacy tab.
Cookie settings in Firefox are managed in the Options window's Privacy panel. See Options window - Privacy Panel for information on these settings.
Click on the spanner icon on the toolbar, select settings, click the under the bonnet tab, click on content settings in the privacy section.
You can manage cookies in Opera if you Click on settings, then Preferences, then Advanced and finally Cookies
Choose Safari, then preferences and then click security. You should then be able to specify if and when Safari should accept cookies.
To manage cookies on your mobile phone please consult your manual or handbook.
If you decline cookies, some aspects of Invest Europe site may not work on your computer or mobile phone and you may not be able to access areas you want on the website. For this reason we recommend that you accept cookies.
If you delete all your cookies you will have to update your preferences with us again and some aspects of our site may not work.
If you use a different device, computer profile or browser you will have to tell us your preferences again.
If you'd like to learn more about cookies in general and how to manage them, visit aboutcookies.org.
We can't be responsible for the content of external websites.Opt-out of cookies